Thursday, November 6, 2008

Rob Reimen

Rob Reimen, in his lecture, talks about the concept of Nihilism. Nihilism is the belief “that nothing has intrinsic value”; Reimen states “we are living in a very Nihilistic society”. Everything is related to ‘how is it good for me?’ and if something wont benefit you, then there is no point in doing it. Nietzsche, essentially the creator of Nihilism, says “According to this view, our existence (action, suffering, willing, feeling) has no meaning”; and someone with that reflection of life cannot help others in a society because he thinks that it is all for naught.

Reimen relates Nihilism to the other points in his lecture by stating that Nihilism is bad for the best society. With its accompanying apathy, its self-centeredness, Reimen says that it can’t be present in the best society, because in the best society there has to be the working together of the masses. Like his statement about non-reading; how we destroy the creative arts by pushing the ‘higher’ learning; math, and history, and english. He finds that Nihilism, is the foundational name of what he is talking about, although he does say that it is a little extreme of a name.

Overall Reimen’s lecture ties together the “best society” and ‘citizenship’. He says that in order for the best society to be just that, the citizen of the society needs to take it upon himself to make it that way. Reimen states many examples of the way that the U.S. American influences our culture. ‘Fox TV needs people to watch it, if people don’t watch it, it goes out of business’ this point correlates with many others that he brought out. Reimen showed the effect that citizens, the ones that direct their society’s ways, is very great. 

Monday, November 3, 2008

Baraka Blog

Baraka, a film with no narrative, shows the vastly different cultures in the world. On one side is the American market place; machines sorting chickens, everyone rushing to get places, and the newest technological gadgets. The other side; child workers in a unhealthy workplace in order to scrape together enough food to feed themselves and their family. The Baraka film compares the “modern age city” to the 3rd world nations and the many cultures that exist. Its argument is one of a simple, yet complex question; Is it ethical that there are cultures that have enough money to be able to fulfill all of the wants of its inhabitants, while other nations don’t have the resources to provide clean drinking water?

Baraka starts with the ever thoughtful monkey. The video portrays him as a thoughtful one, sitting in the pool of water, thinking. He closes his eyes in an almost sad, reflective way, begging to see ethics of the world that we live in. The next scenes show the elegance of nature and cultures, like monks preforming the “Monkey” chant. The point of these clips, is to show the elegance that exists in nature. Then the sudden falling of the tree, and the piercing stare of the Indian leader, and the questioning shy face of the child who doesn’t understand why there is a need to blow out huge caverns of rock. Then the overpopulation and poverty of cities that now inhabit a once natural beautiful valley.

The ethical statement here; starting from the reflective monkey to the child wondering why, is composed of the comparison of the natural world to the mechanized one. Baraka shows that this new ‘civilization’ is unethical by the standards of the old. Progressing from the monks who respect and care for their environment, to the “hotel civilization” as Cornel West would put it. This emerging hotel civilization has, and will continue to utterly destroy forests to make room for itself. This beast of a culture needs food. That supply comes from all over the world, trees from ancient rain-forests; and “precious” metals from man-made creators of mining. This radical change in the way that cultures deal with the environment, can be viewed as either unethical, or that the meaning of “ethical” changes to fit the culture.

The next parts of the Baraka film show the effects of this change in the way that the cultures operate. Instead of working in independent groups, most of the world now feeds the few nations that are able to live the hotel life, and not think of where that cigarette came from, those child labor factories, stuffed, and with low wages. The film then moves to the best clip; a monk walking down a crowded city street very slowly ringing his bell, asking for donations. No one gives; and he is alone, despite being in a wealthy city with people walking by in thousands of dollars worth of accessories, no one gives.

An ethical statement; in a wealthy, crowded city, no one bothers to spare some change for the monk walking down the road. Surely no one would think that he is not important; they just have better things to do with their money, like by the new HDTV that just came out. The “flat world”, as Thomas Friedmen would put it, is one of equality, and everyone playing on the same ‘soccer field’ for jobs. However, how equal can this flat world be; there is war, poverty, genocide, child labor, this all plays into a different view. That view being a view of power, there is the separation between 1st world countries and 3rd world countries for a reason. Those children in the cigarette factory make a very miniscule amount; and then the products created are sold to the nations with power. In this uneven “flat world” the 3rd world serves the 1st world in one way or another.

Baraka starts out with the monkey. Sitting in a pool with the effect of thinking through the events of recent, and wondering how it came to this. The film runs through the degregation of nature, and the overrunning of the binge culture. The hotel civilization, the thinkingly ‘unlimited powered America’, the supposed flat world. This all is connected into the thematic, ethical question of Baraka. Is it ethical for the 3rd world countries to be serving the 1st world nation, when they can barely support themselves? In short, no. It is the epitome of the hotel civilization to not realize what is being given to support the beast of consumption. America needs to wake up from its bingeing ways and fix itself so that it no longer taxing 3rd world countries that are desperate for work. The monkey shall sit in its pool until America awakens, and the monks will continue their Monkey chant; it is time, America.